Nine players? Odd numbers at five-a-side
The magic man, rolling subs, a keeper who swaps sides: tried and tested ways to make an odd number of players work.
Updated November 2026
It's ten to seven, you're standing by the pitch and you've counted nine. Or eleven, because someone brought a mate without asking.
Odd numbers happen to every five-a-side, and the game doesn't have to suffer. Here are the formats that work for 7, 9, 11 and more.
In short
- Nine: four against four plus a "magic man" who plays for whoever has the ball, or five against four with a handicap and a swap at half time.
- Eleven: five against five with a rolling sub who swaps in every few minutes.
- Seven or eight: three or four a side on a narrower pitch, or no keepers and small goals.
- Twelve or more: rolling subs on both sides, or split into two games if you've got the space.
- Agree the format before kick-off, not after the first goal.
Nine players
Nine is the most common odd number by far: ten said yes, one didn't make it. You've got a few good options, and a way to play if you end up as the four.
The magic man
Play four against four, and the ninth player plays for whichever team has the ball. Every attack is five against four, so the games are open and full of goals.
The magic man never defends, so it suits someone who can pass. Swap the job round every ten minutes, or every few goals, so everyone gets a go.
Agree one thing first: can the magic man score? Most groups say no, or only from inside the other half. Keep the rest simple: whoever has the ball, has the magic man.
Five against four, with a handicap
Keep proper teams, five against four, and give the four a helping hand. The one that works best: the five can only shoot from the other team's half. They have to work the ball forward, which gives the four time to get back.
If that's not enough, add one of these:
- The four get a rush goalie (some call it a fly keeper): the last player back can use their hands in the area, and can come out and play. It's the four's best weapon: see how to play as the four.
- The four's goals count double. Crude, but it keeps the four interested when it's 6–2.
- The five have two-touch. A good leveller if the five are also the stronger side.
Put your strongest player in the four, not the five. It does more for the balance than any rule.
The halfway swap
Play five against four in the first half. At half time, the team of four chooses a player from the five to come over to their side, and the second half is four against five the other way.
It makes both halves matter. The team with five has to build a big lead in the first half, because they'll be defending it a player down in the second. And the four get to pick who they take, so they'll take the player who hurt them most.
The keeper swaps sides
Play four outfield players a side with one keeper. The keeper plays for orange in the first half and lime in the second, so each team has a keeper for half the game and a rush goalie for the other half.
It works best when you've got someone who likes going in goal. Playing in goal covers the rush goalie properly.
How to play as the four
Whichever handicap you use, the four need a plan. The worst thing you can do as the four is press high: they just pass it round you and they're through.
Instead, sit deep and make them come to you. With a rush goalie, one of you covers the goal and the other three sit in a low block, just outside your area. Let them have the ball until they get near your goal.
- One engages the ball. When it comes down one side, the nearest of the three goes and meets it.
- Two mark the middle, man for man. That's where the goals come from.
- The far side is left. Their spare player is usually out there, overlapping. Leave them, for now.
- Shuffle across. If the ball's worked over to that side, the whole three shift: one of the middle two goes out to meet it, and the others slide over behind. Left, right, left, right, all game.
Then break, and break quickly. When you win it, or the keeper gathers it, there's a moment when they're all forward. A rush goalie can come out with the ball and start the break. You won't get many chances, so take the ones you get.
Eleven players: rolling subs
Eleven is five a side plus one spare. Don't make the spare sit out a whole half. Roll them in.
- Swap every five minutes, or every goal, whichever comes first. Someone on the side keeps an eye on the time.
- Go round in order, so nobody sits out twice before everyone has once.
- The sub joins the team that's losing if the score gets lopsided. That keeps it close.
- Swap on the move. The player coming off walks to the halfway line, and the sub goes on as they arrive. No stopping the game.
With eleven, the sub can also play magic man for a while: five against five with a sixth for whoever has the ball. It gets frantic, but it's fun for ten minutes.
Seven players
Seven is three against three plus one. The magic man works well here too: three a side with a magic man is four against three every attack. Or play four against three, with a rush goalie for the three and the four not allowed to score from their own half.
Think about the pitch. Six or seven people on a full five-a-side pitch is a lot of running, and the game can turn into long balls and tired legs.
Eight or fewer: shrink the pitch
Four against four is a fine game, and so is three against three, as long as the space fits.
- Make the pitch narrower. Use cones, bags or bottles to bring the sides in. Fewer players need less width.
- Drop the keepers. Play with small goals (two cones a stride apart at each end) and no keepers. Every player is in the game the whole time.
- Only score from inside the area. It changes the game: no pot shots, so you have to pass and run your way in. It's one for four against four or three against three; with nine on the pitch the area gets too crowded.
- Shorten the game, or take breaks. Fewer players means more running each. Play shorter halves and rest in between.
- Play a game instead of a match. Below six, try keep-ball, or a shooting game with a keeper. Nobody minds for one week.
Some centres will move you to a smaller pitch if you ask, and some won't. Either way, the pitch is paid for, so make the most of it.
Twelve or more
A good problem to have. With twelve, rolling subs on both sides works: one sub each, swapping every five minutes. With thirteen or fourteen it's one or two on the side for each team.
Past fourteen, people sit out too much. If you've got room, split into two games: two three-a-side games across the pitch with small goals, or ask the centre if the next pitch is free.
If you haven't, play ten-minute games and rotate three teams: winners stay on, or every team plays every other. It's how many end-of-season nights work: see ending the season in style.
Regularly getting twelve or more? Think about two pitches, or choosing ten each week and keeping the others as reserves.
Agree it before kick-off
Whatever you play, agree the format before kick-off, not after the first goal: who's the magic man, who swaps at half time, can they score. Rules agreed after a goal are just arguments. If yours come up every week, write them into your house rules.
Picking the teams
Odd numbers make fair teams harder, not easier. In a five against four, the four needs to be the stronger four. With rolling subs, put the weakest player on as the sub first, so they get a rest without either team losing its best player.
On 5asider there's no fixed team size, so you can put whoever's in into two teams of any size and swap people about before you save. Auto-pick splits them from the squad's own results. Picking fair teams goes into the methods, and if you're short every week, finding players is the longer fix.
Questions people ask
How do you play five-a-side with nine players?
Either four against four with a magic man who plays for whoever has the ball, or five against four with a handicap such as the five only being allowed to shoot from the other team's half.
How do you make five against four fair?
Let the five shoot only from the other team's half, and swap one over at half time: the four pick a player from the five to join them for the second half. The five then have to build a lead before half time, because they'll defend it a player down.
How do you defend with four against five?
Don't press high. Keep a rush goalie covering the goal and three outfield players sitting deep: one meets the ball, two mark the middle, and all three shuffle across when the ball switches sides. Win it, then break quickly.
What is a magic man in football?
A neutral player who joins whichever team has the ball. It turns every attack into an overload and is the go-to fix for odd numbers.
How do rolling subs work at five-a-side?
The spare player swaps in every few minutes or after each goal, in a fixed order, coming on by the halfway line without stopping the game.
Can you play five-a-side with eight?
Yes: four against four, ideally on a narrower pitch or with small goals and no keepers. Try "only score from inside the area" for a change.
Where this comes from
This guide comes from Martin's own games at The Tuesdays FC: the formats for seven, nine, eleven and twelve or more, and how to play as the four.
Advertisement
Whatever the numbers, get a game on.
Create a squad, add your players and your first game in a few minutes. Free, nothing to install, and players reply from the email.